HERMES - User Manual
| Getting started | Starting a new discussion | Argumentation elements | Submitting argumentation elements |
The Discussion Forum user interface | Advanced Discourse Acts |

| Back to the Contents | Back to the Hermes Home Page | Back to the Action AID Home Page |


Argumentation elements

Once you have started a discussion, setting also up the initial issue, you should know the argumentation elements allowed in the system. These are issues, alternatives, positions (pro and con) and constraints.

A position always refers to a single other position or alternative, while an alternative or issue is always in a single issue. Constraints may refer to another constraint, a position, or an issue.

Alternatives, positions and constraints can be active or inactive, depending on their proof standards (see the Submitting argumentation elements section) and the argumentation underneath. Constraints can be consistent or inconsistent, depending on the other constraints of the same issue.

Active alternatives correspond to ``recommended'' choices, i.e., choices that are the strongest among the alternatives in their issue. Active positions are considered ``accepted'' due to the discussion underneath (e.g., strong supporting arguments, no counter-arguments), while inactive positions are considered ``rejected'' and are not taken into account. The mechanisms for the calculation of activation labels are described in .


| Getting started | Starting a new discussion | Argumentation elements | Submitting argumentation elements |
The Discussion Forum user interface | Advanced Discourse Acts |

| Back to the Contents | Back to the Hermes Home Page | Back to the Action AID Home Page |


Last update: October 20, 1997
Nikos Karacapilidis