|
Inria STARS
Deep Learning for Computer Vision |
|
Winter 2023 |
|
Project Topics
We suggest 1 or 2 people as a team
Option 1: Choose from the suggested papers (updating)
Option 2: Your own project.
You can also pick papers from CVPR/ICCV/ECCV/NeuRIPS/ICLR/ICML. You also let us know before...
Grading Policy
Final project: 100%
Tips on how to read a machine learning scientific paper
(as stated in the slides from the first lecture):
Tips on writing a paper review
(Based on example review forms, from the 2020 AAAI conference)
Address the following parts:
- Motivation/Relevance: why did the authors do what they did?
- Related work/Novelty: how is this situated in the research field/current state-of-the-art?
- Contribution: what is the presented contribution exactly, what does it do and how does it work?
- Support/Evaluation/Correctness: how are the claims supported: theory and/or empirical evaluation?
- Impact/Significance: how will this work change the world?
- Writing/Clarity: how easy was it to read?
For most of these categories, it is good to both highlight the authors' view and your own interpretation on it.
Exemplary format:
- 1. [Summary] Please summarize the main claims/contributions of the paper in your own words.
- 2. [Relevance] Is this paper relevant to an AI audience?
- 3. [Significance] Are the results significant?
- 4. [Novelty] Are the problems or approaches novel?
- 5. [Soundness] Is the paper technically sound?
- 6. [Evaluation] Are claims well-supported by theoretical analysis or experimental results?
- 7. [Clarity] Is the paper well-organized and clearly written?
- 8. [Detailed Comments] Please elaborate on your assessments and provide constructive feedback.
- 9. [QUESTIONS FOR THE AUTHORS] Please provide questions for authors to address during the author feedback period. (E.g. if something is unclear to you)