Mapping DebateGraph > SALT Rhetorical Ontology OR > Sioc Arguments

namespaces:

sro (SALT)=http://salt.semanticauthoring.org/ontologies/sro#

sioc=http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#

siocarg=http://rdfs.org/sioc/argument

swanrel=http://swan.mindinformatics.org/ontologies/1.2/discourse-relationships/

swanel=http://swan.mindinformatics.org/ontologies/1.2/discourse-elements/

Debate Graph

TENTATIVE BUNDLE

CLASSES

examples

class

note

issue (Raise an issue)

Is disarmament achievable?

sioc:Issue (subOf Statement)

position ( State a position on an issue)

Disarmament is achievable

sioc:Position

category

skos:Category

position's component

US Disarmament is achievable

cf partOf problem ?

sioc:Argument

supporting argument

Start treaty reduces US-Russia arsenal

sioc:Justification (subOf Argument)

opposing argument

Disarmament is unverifiable

sioc:Argument sioc:challenges sioc:Position

part of argument

US disarmament is unverifiable

cf partOf problem ?

group of arguments

cf sioc:related_to

cf the alignment between

debate protagonist

Greenpeace

foaf:Agent (Person, Organization, etc)

swanel:DiscourseElement and sioc:Item

repertoire of options

?

decision

sioc:Decision

task

?

scenario

?

PROPERTIES

Link between nodes

Examples

domain

range

property

domain

range

hasCategory

Politics

issue

category

dcterms:subject

siocarg:Issue

skos:Category

hasEquivalence

position

position

owl:sameAs (?)

siocarg:Position

siocarg:Position

hasVariation

position

position

rdf:seeAlso ? or skos:mappingRelations

siocarg:Position

siocarg:Position

hasGrounding

Position

supporting_argument

sioc:agrees_with

Position

sioc:Justification

hasCausation

?

?

swanrel:motivatedBy ?

hasConsistency

position

position

swanrel:consistentWith

hasInconsistency

position

position

swanrel:inconsistentWith

advocates

debateProtagonist

Position

? hyvocarg:advocates ?

foaf:Agent

siocarg:Position

hasRelevance

any node

any node

sioc:related_to ?

hasResponsibility

?

task ?

?