Please fill this form and return it by e-mail to ejck@sophia.inria.fr
 

Back to EJCK home page

Paper Number:
 

Abbreviated Title:
 

Author(s):
 

Originality:
 
 

• Never been done before
• Never been done this way before
• Minor variation of a known technique. See following references:

• Re-invention of a known technique. See following references:

Previous publication:

Has this paper been previously published ?

If yes does the changes warrant publication in EJCK ?

Relevance to EJCK:
 

• Poor
• Marginal
• Acceptable
• Good
• Excellent

Engineering relevance:
 

• Importnat problem of current interest
• Part of a problem of current interest
• The solution is a significant contribution
• An interesting insight
• Recreational

Soundness
 

• technically sound
• contains errors of detail (please explain in your comments)
• seriously flawed (please explain in your comments)

References
 

• Too many references of marginal value
• Important references missing (please provide references in your comments)
• Adequate references
• Totally inadequate references

• Unnecessarily detailed (please explain)
• enough for a graduate student to reproduce the core ofthe work
• enough for the reviewer to reproduce the core of the work
• no-one can reproduce the work  (please explain)

• Understood at first reading
• Several readings required
• It would take a long time to understand this paper

Presentation

• Title is not appropriate
• Abstract is not appropriate
• Poor figures
• Paper is too long/too short (please explain)
• Rearrangements are needed (please explain)

 

Animation

• None
• Poor
• Acceptable
• Good
• Excellent
• Honor

Adequacy of the results with EJCK benches
 

• no EJCK bench for this problem
• results for EJCK benches are presented
• results for EJCK benches are not presented

Would you recommend this paper for a "Best paper" award from the EJCK board ?
 

• Yes
• No

• Yes
• No

Confidential comments to the Board
 

Detailed comments to the author(s)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Reviewer name:

Reviewer e-mail

Date
 
 

Back to EJCK home page